Black Cat Pizzeria signage at night

4 of our Favorite Pizzerias on Amelia Island

Pizza is one of the most iconic “American” foods that you can find anywhere, but finding good pizza is sometimes a struggle. Whether you are a New Yorker looking for pizza by the slice, create your own options, or from a wood-fired oven, Amelia Island has a pizzeria that fits your taste buds. That’s why we compiled a list of some of the best options for pizza on Amelia Island!

New to the area and looking for inspiration when you go out on the town? Then, be sure to get your copy of our free Vacation Guide. Inside, you’ll find even more thoughtful insight on the best things to do, places to eat, and attractions to see while you’re in town.

The 4 Best Pizza Restaurants Near Amelia Island

Black Cat Pizzeria

A new entry to the Fernandina Beach-Yulee scene, Black Cat Pizzeria has been serving up “Southern” style pizzas since early 2022. Enjoy pizzas by the slice, fresh calzones made to order, and big salads while eschewing the strict standards of the New York pizza scene.

Natural Slice Pizza and Surf Shop

Nestled in The Shops at Omni Amelia Island, Natural Slice Pizza & Surf Shop is not your typical pizza joint. The Amelia Island fixture serves a thin-crust pizza with a bevy of topping options made to impress everyone in your family! The fun location is a great place for an afternoon drink and has fun video and physical games like billiards to play.

Stop by Natural Slice Pizza & Surf Shop for the pizza and stay for the fun atmosphere when you visit!

Townies Pizzeria

Enjoy a farm-fresh pizza with a side of piracy when you weigh anchor at Townies Pizzeria. This locally owned, pirate-themed pizzeria prides itself on its scratch-made NYC-style pizza and Italian-American classics like the chicken parm sandwich. This husband and wife duo has been serving pizzas and giving back to the local Amelia Island community monthly which is why they are one of our favorites.

Arte Pizza

Found a block from downtown Fernandina Beach, Arte Pizza’s mission is to serve sustainably sourced wood-fired pizza to hungry Amelia Island residents and visitors. Since 2006, Arte Pizza has succeeded in providing that unique taste of a wood-fired pizza with attention to detail and numerous options like their: white pie, aloha, and rustica.

If you are in the mood for some good Italian-American menu options then you will be happy with the Mama’s meatball sub, their Calzones, and the freshly made focaccia bread. Mangia Mangia when you stop by at Arte Pizza!

The Fairbanks House

After visiting your new favorite local pizzeria, stretch out on our porch at The Fairbanks House in downtown Amelia Island! Our historic house is both relaxing and inviting and the perfect place to stay while you explore the greater Fernandina Beach area. There’s no better destination to call your home away from home during your visit to Fernandina Beach.

Check our availability and book your stay today