Amelia Island Bakeries

4 Bakeries on Amelia Island that Demand Your Tastebuds Listen

It is always fun to see what good things local bakeries are crafting whenever you travel. From the sweet confections of French Macarons and cupcakes to the warmth and texture of fresh bread, local bakeries are often underrated. That’s why we compiled a list of some of the best options for bakeries on Amelia Island! Many of our favorite local bakeries and cafes feature a wide range of sweet and savory goods such as pastries, cookies, breads, and cakes.

New to the area and looking for inspiration when you go out on the town? Then, be sure to get your copy of our free Vacation Guide. Inside, you’ll find even more thoughtful insight on the best things to do, places to eat, and attractions to see while you’re in town.

Top 4 Bakeries on Amelia Island

Nana Teresa’s Bake Shop

Nana Teresa’s Bake Shop’s bright and vibrant colors make it easy to spot in downtown Fernandina Beach. Priding itself as a “bakery filled with love,” you can find everything from colorful French Macaron cookies to key lime pie to tiramisu. Nana Teresa’s dessert selection is endless, and they are also home to a 1950’s era soda fountain so you can relive your childhood and order an authentic milkshake, float, or banana split.

Europa Delicatessen

While it has delicatessen in the name, Europa Delicatessen specializes in more than just deli meats and sandwiches. Explore the finest of the Old World including meats and cheeses you would be hard-pressed to find elsewhere when you visit this new Amelia Island destination.

Redbones Gourmet Dog Bakery and Boutique

Your dog deserves some love while you are here! Visit Redbones Gourmet Dog Bakery and Boutique for freshly baked dog treats for dogs (and cats) of all sizes. Take back something for everyone in your family when you include the dog on your Amelia Island vacation. We think your furry friend will especially love the Vanilla Jimmies which are handmade, decorated, and packaged in the bakery.

Stephanie’s Sugar and Spice Cafe

Another downtown delight, Stephanie’s Sugar and Spice Cafe can be identified by their pink building on Centre Street. Enjoy sitting outside in the Florida sunshine and enjoy the finer things in life. You will never know what sugary or savory treat awaits you at Stephanie’s Sugar and Spice Cafe and that is half the charm!

The Fairbanks House

After visiting your new favorite local bakery, stretch out on our porch at The Fairbanks House in downtown Amelia Island! Our historic house is both relaxing and inviting and the perfect place to stay while you explore the greater Fernandina Beach area. There’s no better destination to call your home away from home during your visit to Fernandina Beach.

Check our availability and book your stay today!